Well, the answer to that is that Santa was in Krampus' sack and then Krampus got swallowed by a magical tar pit that makes people forget the thing existed. And by the time the Legacies kids saved him ... your dad had been dead for a really long time.

Sorry, Dylan. Time was not on your side.

Also it's probably for the best there's a skeptic around. The kids probably need a reality check every once in a while.

"You'll get used to it once you get started. If you get started. Headmaster Forbes didn't mention if she'd sealed the deal, so to speak."